Dilemmas : the Tarner lectures 1953

by Gilbert Ryle

I did something yesterday, so it was true a thousand years ago that I was going to do it. Could I help it, then? Professor Ryle shows that I could; he also shows that a dilemma like this starts with a slender base - the question whether statements in the future can be true - and opens out before one notices it into questions like 'is it worthwhile learning to swim?' In his second demonstration Professor Ryle proves that Achilles will after all overtake his tortoise and will not have to pursue it through all eternity. These two puzzles were classic if academic examples of the dilemmas Professor Ryle is concerned with. Common sense tells me that I can to some extent control my life; should I then, faced with an apparently logical argument for fatalism, reject common sense? Again, because I enjoy or dislike things, are all my actions due to the seeking of pleasure and the avoidance of pain? Because my eyes and ears tell me one set of things about the world and science tels me another, am I to think my senses less reliable or accurate than science? Professor Ryle's aim is to arbitrate between these pairs of theories which compete for our allegiance, and to show that the either/or which they seem to insist on is a false dilemma. It may lead to mere muddle, or to a more subtle confusion; either way these tugs-of-war between conflicting theories may bring the ordinary man either to confused or wrong action or to intellectual apathy.

「Nielsen BookData」より


  • 1. Dilemmas
  • 2. 'It was to be'
  • 3. Achilles and the tortoise
  • 4. Pleasure
  • 5. The world of science and the everyday world
  • 6. Technical and untechnical concepts
  • 7. Perception
  • 8. Formal and informal logic.

「Nielsen BookData」より


書名 Dilemmas : the Tarner lectures 1953
著作者等 Ryle, Gilbert
出版元 Cambridge University Press
刊行年月 1960
ページ数 129 p.
大きさ 21 cm
ISBN 0521091152
NCID BA07461912
※クリックでCiNii Booksを表示
言語 英語
出版国 イギリス